Tarik Skubal could sign the richest pitching contract in baseball history within the next two weeks.

The two-time Cy Young winner recorded a 2.72 ERA in 2026 before entering free agency after a blockbuster trade from Detroit to Los Angeles. That trade also made him ineligible for a qualifying offer, eliminating draft-pick compensation as an obstacle for interested teams.

The Mets are favorites, but recent developments suggest this is not a two-team race between New York and the Dodgers.

Is Toronto the strongest challenger?

Skubal met with the Mets on Monday, November 16, followed by the Dodgers and Blue Jays on Tuesday. San Diego is expected to meet with him later this week, while two additional interested clubs remain unidentified.

According to MLB.com's November 18 report, ESPN's Buster Olney says some people involved in negotiations expect the final bidding to come down to the Mets and Toronto.

Jeff Passan reports that Toronto has money available and wants to pair Skubal with Dylan Cease. Meanwhile, the Dodgers reportedly prefer a shorter contract, conflicting with Skubal's desire for a long-term commitment.

The Mets still have the strongest reported position, but Toronto has a credible route to winning: offering the length and money Skubal wants.

How does the CBA change the race?

The current collective bargaining agreement expires December 1 at 11:59 p.m. ET. An expected lockout would freeze major-league signings and trades until a new agreement is reached.

MLB's latest proposal would introduce a $258.2 million salary cap and $180.2 million floor beginning in 2028—not immediately in 2027. MLB identified all four known Skubal suitors among teams that would need to reduce spending under that proposed system, based on 2026 payrolls.

But the players' union opposes the cap, and no agreement has been reached. Signing Skubal before December provides certainty about his destination, not a guaranteed exemption from future labor rules.

Which prediction-market underdogs offer value?

In a November 18 check of Kalshi's Skubal market, Toronto displayed a 12% chance. The Dodgers displayed 22% with a 24¢ YES quote; the earlier supplied screenshot showed San Diego at 6% but a 13¢ YES quote.

Those differences matter: the price paid, not the displayed probability, determines the break-even point.

At Toronto's 15¢ quote, 100 YES contracts would cost $15 plus approximately 90¢ in standard taker fees under Kalshi's fee schedule. Holding to settlement requires a true probability above 15.9% to have positive expected value.

For illustration, estimating Toronto's chance at 20% would produce $4.10 in expected profit per 100 contracts after that entry fee. But 20% is hypothetical; the reporting establishes serious interest, not a verified probability.

Could a prolonged lockout create another opportunity?

Kalshi's contract has an unusual alternative: “Retires / No Team” wins if Skubal remains unsigned on March 25, 2027.

That makes a lengthy lockout relevant, but not automatically profitable. The previous MLB lockout lasted 99 days, ending March 10, 2022. An identical timetable this winter would still leave roughly two weeks for Skubal to sign before Kalshi's deadline.

MLB Network's Jon Heyman expects Skubal to sign before December 1, which further weakens the no-team scenario.